Whose Face Belongs Here? Navigating Race in the World of AI

Advertisement

By Jim Betz

I was thrown a curveball recently when I tried a brand new lesson with a second-grade class that involved AI. The general idea of the lesson involved groups of kids devising a basic outline for a tall tale, then entering it into ChatGPT to generate a story on a second-grade reading level.

As a demonstration, I modelled developing a character for such a tale, and on a whim chose to base the character on myself: the story of a librarian who could shelve books at lightning speed. We were pleased with the results, and asked ChatGPT to create an illustration for the story.

The second graders, having little or no experience with AI, didn’t know what to expect, but a few expressed surprise when the illustration showed a character that was of a different race than myself. When several students tried to point out that the illustration didn’t accurately reflect me, I explained that I was merely using my name and job as a model for the character; it was never meant to represent me directly.

Not a big deal, and the class proceeded normally after. But the fact that programs like ChatGPT or Google’s Gemini can create illustrations involving people does raise a few questions for those teachers who wish to integrate them into their daily lessons—and may lead to discussions on topics we aren’t used to bringing up in class.

I decided to see how my teacher colleagues would handle a similar issue. Most of the ones I spoke to in a highly informal survey said they expected the kids to accept the illustration as the AI created it, and wouldn’t address the topic of race at all. However, I don’t feel we’re really serving our students when an issue such as racial representation comes up and is pushed to the side.

How should a teacher respond to students asking to regenerate an AI image with people of a particular race? Anyone familiar with using AI to create images of people knows that it is possible to revise these images to make a character taller, older, thinner, with a different hair color, etc.

There have been times that I’ve needed to specify the race of a character for my own work. When I create an AI image, though, I’m familiar with who I am representing and their origin; usually I create AI images for stories or podcasts in which the main character is well developed and has a sense of identity.

For educators who are teaching writing or computer science and having students generate images of characters that have just been dreamed up moments before, would it be a red line for a child to specify a certain race when formulating their character?

I image that this could be an issue for older students—the kind of issue that keeps them talking long after the class has ended. When we ask students to come up with adjectives to define how a character looks, should we now be teaching them tactful ways to assign race as well? In a racially sensitive atmosphere, would a teacher attach any importance if a student were to specify a character’s race in an AI-generated image? This could potentially lead to the perpetuation of stereotypes, such as specifying white police officers or African American criminals.

Moreover, if a teacher overlooks the issue, they may be choosing not to address a critical thinking skill that students could utilize while using AI at home. And they will use AI to create images at home. They will also encounter AI-generated images on their own time on websites that may have racial or ethnic agendas.

Until AI has been perfected enough to be flawless—something that may never happen—the issue of race in AI-generated images will come up in the classroom. A New York Times article recently addressed Google’s Gemini AI system which, when asked to generate images of German soldiers in World War II, produced images that included an African American man and an Asian woman.

The Times article raised enough controversy to cause a temporary suspension in images involving humans, but it’s doubtful that any company’s good intentions regarding diversity will infallibly be guided by historical accuracy. The students sitting in classrooms today need to learn how to evaluate the products of artificial intelligence, and model an acceptable means of communicating those issues of race that do arise.

As students shift from seeking information to navigating a flood of content generated and curated by algorithms, the classroom must evolve just as quickly. Generative AI is not a distant, futuristic tool—it’s already here, shaping the way students think, create, and question. As school districts begin to introduce AI training, the focus should move beyond mere fascination with what AI can do, and instead should prioritize thoughtful engagement with what it means.

Teachers need support not only in understanding the tools, but also in managing the ethical, cultural, and emotional complexities AI brings to the classroom. Preparing for these moments—when a student’s curiosity brushes up against real-world sensitivities—is no longer optional. It’s essential.

Jim Betz is a media specialist working at a primary (K–2) school in Georgia. He previously taught art and computer science, but loves being in the library because it lets him use art and technology in creative ways with the kids.

Education News

Is Your Child’s Literacy on Vacation? How Parents Can Beat the Summer Slide

Did you know students can lose up to two months of learning progress over summer break? Here's how to tackle the “summer slide” and keep kids engaged.

Nominations Open for Heroes of the Classroom Teacher Recognition Program

Nominations are accepted through August 3. Ten finalists will advance to a public vote for the chance to win the Grand Prize—valued at approximately $16,000 in cash and prizes.

New School Safety Trends Report Shows Training and Technology Are Saving Lives in U.S. Schools

CENTEGIX’s 2025 School Safety Trends Report reveals a national movement toward proactive, integrated school safety strategies, including campus mapping.

Girls Experienced Disproportionate Setbacks in STEM Skills Post-COVID

COVID-19 has been an unequal crisis, disrupting learning more deeply for some student groups than others.

Join Our Newsletter

Get 10% off a subscription, monthly giveaways, and the latest updates—straight to your inbox!

Jim Betz
Jim Betz
Jim Betz is a media specialist working at a primary (K–2) school in Georgia. He previously taught art and computer science, but loves being in the library because it lets him use art and technology in creative ways with the kids.

Advertisement

Read More

Guardians of the Coast: Building Kids’ Confidence Through Art

I was recently involved with an art exhibition in the Thanet District of Kent, England, that helped students see themselves as artists, advocates, and changemakers.

Is Your Child’s Literacy on Vacation? How Parents Can Beat the Summer Slide

Did you know students can lose up to two months of learning progress over summer break? Here's how to tackle the “summer slide” and keep kids engaged.

The Power of Music and Melody: Using Songs to Engage Young Learners

By harnessing the power of music, teachers can create a lively and dynamic atmosphere that also improves concentration, focus, and retention.

Nominations Open for Heroes of the Classroom Teacher Recognition Program

Nominations are accepted through August 3. Ten finalists will advance to a public vote for the chance to win the Grand Prize—valued at approximately $16,000 in cash and prizes.

Real (and Really Funny) Math

I'm an author of math books, which may sound like a dry job, but that’s exactly why I do it. It’s my goal to show kids that math can be fun (and funny!)

New School Safety Trends Report Shows Training and Technology Are Saving Lives in U.S. Schools

CENTEGIX’s 2025 School Safety Trends Report reveals a national movement toward proactive, integrated school safety strategies, including campus mapping.
tạo dàn 3d | hôm nay đánh de con gì | augsburg đấu với dortmund | huong duong nguoc nang tap 40 | clip casino campuchia | dac biet năm | casino babylon macau | blv giàng a phof trực tiếp | casino with poker tables near me | thai casino online | chống chuột khoang máy ô tô | trang ve thon da mp3 | royal casino restaurant | casino png | trực tiếp bóng đá 101tv | agree gì | nieuwe casino online | mod skin lq | ipad 6th generation sim card slot | đăng ký làm đại lý ku casino | willy wonka slots | casino đà nẵng | android casino bonus | eurogrand casino free spins | thai casino online | vòng loại world cup 2022 khu vực bắc mỹ | online casino pay by sms | ohaytv | snake eyes casino | slot jerry | tinchihau | casino queen | express casino | maxims club casino | slotland casino | time slot booking | betphoenix casino | du doan ket qua xo so quang ngai | quay thử xổ số đà nẵng giờ hoàng đạo | sunwin casino | venus casino ae888 | real cash online casino | con rắn số mấy | top casino games | c88 | venetian casino | f88 la gì | irish luck casino no deposit bonus | tetri mania slot | slot attendant | casino vietnam | cassava slot sites | dell vostro 3578 m2 slot | the witcher 3 skill slots | casino 1995 trailer | igram io | online slot machines that pay real money | online casino blog | the westin las vegas hotel casino & spa | kq7 | việc làm 123 | doc truyen ngon tinh |